I would chose Plymouth because you would not not get shot every time you stepped outside,and at Plymouth  you cold actually grow  plants.They also had friendly indians as there neighbor.The indians helped the seprests grow crops.At Jamestown they indians killed the colonists,The colonists and the indians had love and hate moments mostly hate.The pilgrims were successful.Meanwhile Jamestown almost failed to establish there town,the colonist faild to plant  crops because it was swampy.